Andrew Welsh-Huggins returns to AHMM in our Nov/Dec issue with “Dog Person,” a continuation of his long-running Andy Hayes series. Here Andrew discusses a unique approach he deploys to keep the series fresh

Readers frequently ask about my strategies for keeping a long-running series fresh. It’s a fair question now that I’m up to eight books and a novella (Rescue Me) in my private eye series featuring Andy Hayes, a former Ohio State and Cleveland Browns quarterback turned investigator.
I follow tried-and-true approaches, including introducing new characters along the way (Hayes learned in 2024’s Sick To Death that he had an adult daughter he was unaware of) and incorporating current events as much as possible (Rescue Me involves a controversy over drag story hours).
My top technique for keeping things interesting, however, is a decision I made when I started my series: aging my characters in real time. When I published the first Hayes book, Fourth Down and Out, in 2014, Hayes’ two sons (each with a different ex-wife) were little kids. Today, they’re college-bound. Hayes, in his early forties at the time, is now approaching the far side of fifty. Adding birthdays to Hayes’ age keeps him on his toes as he faces new personal and professional challenges. He’s wiser and more mature, for instance, but knocking heads takes a heavier toll as the years march on.
Different writers take different approaches. Sue Grafton opted to keep Kinsey Millhone in her thirties by setting the entire series in the 1980s. Robert B. Parker did not age his private eye, Spenser, and even as other authors have continued the series, Spenser is the same age as he was when the books began in the 1970s. Michael Connelly’s characters, by contrast, are growing old: in his newest novel, Ironwood, retired LAPD Detective Harry Bosch—who debuted in 1993’s The Black Echo—is described as an old man.
Throughout my Andy Hayes books, his yellow lab, Hopalong (named for former Ohio State football star Howard “Hopalong” Cassaday) has made frequent appearances. Several readers have told me that Hopalong adds realism to the books: they appreciate the fact that before Hayes can solve a mystery or save the day, he has to make sure Hopalong has been walked and fed. In keeping with my approach, Hopalong was a frisky dog that Hayes could take on runs in the first couple of books in the series. By the time Rescue Me came out earlier this year, Hopalong struggles to walk and the end is clearly near.
In “Dog Person,” my short story in the new issue of Alfred Hitchcock Mystery Magazine, I decided to tackle the subject I’d long dreaded: the death of Hayes’ beloved pet. I had personal experience to draw on, having said goodbye to our own beloved dog, as well as numerous cats. But I also consulted a veterinarian friend to be sure I had details of those last moments correct.
The death of Hopalong informs the story, although the mystery within the tale extends beyond that sad event. Nevertheless, forcing Hayes to confront such a loss, as painful as it is for him (and frankly, for me as well), was one more attempt to hopefully keep this series fresh and relevant.









